When you're considering a luxury home in Bend, the asking price tells you what the seller would like to receive.
But what does the market evidence say?
That's a question I take seriously when I represent a buyer. When I prepare a comparative market analysis, or CMA, I try to be disciplined about the sales I use and the conclusions I draw from them.
Because a comparable sale can be perfectly real and not truly a comparable.
I generally start close to the property and with recent sales. Ideally, I want to find genuinely comparable homes within about half a mile that sold within the previous six months.
When those sales exist, they can give us a very useful picture of what buyers have recently been willing to pay.
However, a home doesn't automatically become a good comparable because it sold recently and happens to be nearby. The next question is whether buyers would actually see the two properties as comparable alternatives.
I saw this firsthand with a buyer I represented in Bend.
She loved a home that was listed for $1,365,000 and asked me what I thought of the price. I had already started looking at the comparable sales, and I told her she probably wasn't going to like my answer.
My CMA came in substantially below the asking price. She decided to pass.
The property later reduced its price and ultimately sold for $1,190,000.
Interestingly, I later saw some of the sales that had been used to support the original asking price. They were legitimate sales, and they weren't far away. But several were in nearby neighborhoods that I didn't consider comparable because homes there commanded higher prices.
That distinction mattered.
Comparable sales give us evidence of what buyers have actually paid for other properties. Recently.
They don't give us a single indisputable answer about what another home is worth.
That's especially important in the luxury market, where properties can differ in ways that are difficult to reduce to square footage and bedroom counts. Views, privacy, architecture, lot characteristics, design, construction quality and location within a neighborhood can all influence what buyers are willing to pay.
A CMA requires judgment about which sales deserve the most weight.
I'm picky about comps.
Recency and proximity matter. So do the characteristics of the property and its location.
Two homes can be quite close geographically and still compete in different segments of the Bend market. Buyers may consistently pay more for one neighborhood, street, view or setting than another.
It's perfectly understandable for a seller who loves a home to look at a similar property in a nearby, higher-priced neighborhood and think, "My house is every bit as nice as that one."
It may be.
But the question for a CMA is different: What have buyers demonstrated that they're willing to pay for comparable properties in this particular market?
I'm a real estate broker, not an appraiser. But when I prepare a CMA, one question I routinely ask myself is:
How would an appraiser look at this?
That helps keep my analysis disciplined.
Appraisers consider factors including the similarity of the properties, location, market conditions and the timing of the sales. The most useful comparable isn't necessarily the property with the most similar square footage or the one that's physically closest. The objective is to identify market evidence that meaningfully helps establish the value of the subject property.
A broker's CMA and an appraisal serve different purposes, but I think that kind of disciplined thinking is useful when I'm helping a buyer evaluate an asking price.
Sometimes there simply aren't enough good recent sales within half a mile.
That can happen with unusual properties, and it can be particularly relevant with higher-end homes. A custom home, exceptional view, unusual lot, distinctive architecture or other characteristics may make genuinely comparable sales scarce.
In that case, the search may need to expand geographically or further back in time.
The important part is understanding why a more distant or older sale is being used and how its differences affect the comparison.
Then we have a different question.
A CMA isn't a command about what you should offer. It's information you can use to decide what a particular home is worth to you.
Sometimes a buyer understands that the market evidence doesn't fully support the price and decides they want the house anyway. A particularly unusual property may be difficult to replace. A view, location, architectural feature or something else about the home may simply matter enough to that buyer to justify paying a premium.
Financing can add another consideration because the lender's appraisal may affect the transaction.
But, ultimately, the buyer makes the decision.
My job is to help my client understand the market evidence as clearly as possible, answer the questions we can answer, pursue additional information when we need it, and then advocate for the best price and terms I can.
The comps don't decide what a home is worth to you. They help you understand what the market says it's worth before you make your decision.